Sore Throat or Tonsillitis? How to Tell the Difference

Sore Throat or Tonsillitis? How to Tell the Difference

Wondering Whether It's a Sore Throat or Tonsillitis?

If you’re dealing with throat discomfort, you might be asking yourself whether it’s a minor sore throat or something more serious like tonsillitis. Not sure when it’s the right time to see a doctor? Let’s break down how to distinguish between these conditions, examine their symptoms, and review the best steps to take.

Understanding a Sore Throat

A sore throat is a common and often uncomfortable condition that can range from a slight scratchiness to significant pain in the throat area, particularly around the pharynx or larynx. It frequently appears during viral illnesses like the flu or the common cold. However, it can also be triggered by various irritants, including cigarette smoke, air pollution, dry indoor air, or allergens. In some instances, issues such as acid reflux or straining your voice - whether from singing, teaching, or talking loudly at events can be to blame. It’s important to note that a sore throat isn’t a standalone illness but rather a sign that your body is responding to some form of irritation or stress.

What Causes a Sore Throat?

The main causes of a sore throat include:

  • Viral infections (cold, flu, nasopharyngitis);
  • Environmental irritants (cigarette smoke, pollution, dry air);
  • Allergies;
  • Gastroesophageal reflux;
  • Vocal strain.

In most cases, a sore throat resolves on its own within a few days without any specific treatment.

What Is Tonsillitis?

Tonsillitis is an acute infection that affects the tonsils, which are small, soft tissue structures located at the back of the throat. This condition leads to painful inflammation and is often accompanied by fever and difficulty swallowing. Tonsillitis can be caused by either viruses or bacteria, with group A streptococcus being one of the most common bacterial culprits.

There are different signs of tonsillitis, including: the tonsils appear red and swollen, a whitish coating is visible on the tonsils, small fluid-filled blisters are present on the tonsils, the tonsils have visible ulcers or lesions.

What to look for when examining your tonsils? 

A proper diagnosis can only be made through a clinical examination by a healthcare professional.

How Can You Tell the Difference Between a Sore Throat and Tonsillitis?

It can be challenging to differentiate between a common sore throat and tonsillitis, as many of their symptoms may overlap. Still, certain indicators can help you tell them apart.

Signs That Suggest a Simple Sore Throat

  • Moderate throat discomfort that does not interfere with swallowing
  • Little to no fever
  • Redness in the throat without any white patches
  • Cold-like symptoms such as a runny nose, cough, or sneezing
  • No swollen or painful lymph nodes

Symptoms That May Indicate Tonsillitis

  • Severe throat pain that makes swallowing difficult
  • High fever (usually above 38°C / 100.4°F)
  • Red, swollen tonsils, sometimes with a white coating
  • Enlarged and tender lymph nodes in the neck
  • Significant fatigue
  • Absence of coughing (especially in bacterial tonsillitis)

If you’re experiencing these more concerning symptoms, it’s best to consult a doctor for a definitive diagnosis and appropriate treatment.

Viral or Bacterial Tonsillitis: Why Does It Matter?

Most cases of tonsillitis are caused by viruses and tend to resolve on their own without medical treatment. However, when the infection is bacterial, particularly those due to group A streptococcus, it requires antibiotic therapy to eliminate the bacteria and prevent complications.

There are key differences between viral and bacterial tonsillitis:

  • Viral tonsillitis: moderate fever, frequent coughing, nasal congestion or runny nose, occasionally swollen lymph nodes, red or blistered tonsils
  • Bacterial tonsillitis: high fever, no cough, painful swollen lymph nodes, red tonsils with white patches, and sometimes abdominal pain in children

Only a rapid diagnostic test performed by a doctor, can accurately determine whether the tonsillitis is bacterial and whether antibiotics are necessary.

When Should You See a Doctor?

If you experience any of the following symptoms, it’s important to consult a healthcare provider:

  • Severe throat pain lasting more than 48 hours
  • Fever above 38°C (100.4°F)
  • Difficulty swallowing saliva or food
  • Swollen and tender lymph nodes in the neck
  • Very red, swollen tonsils or ones covered with white coatings
  • Trouble breathing or opening your mouth
  • The appearance of red spots on the skin, abdominal pain, or vomiting
  • High-risk medical conditions (e.g. weakened immune system, chronic illnesses, pregnancy)

In urgent situations such as breathing difficulty, significant neck swelling, or high fever with deteriorating overall condition- seek emergency care immediately. Don’t hesitate to call emergency services (000).

How to Relieve a Sore Throat

If your sore throat is mild and not accompanied by a high fever, you can manage it at home with simple measures. Drink fluids regularly, especially warm beverages, to keep the throat moist and ease the burning sensation. Avoid irritants such as smoking, alcohol, and spicy foods. If the air is dry, consider using a humidifier.

For pain or fever, medications like paracetamol or ibuprofen can be taken - always following the recommended dosages. Throat-soothing treatments like lozenges, sprays, or gargles can offer temporary relief. If you also have cold symptoms, nasal irrigation can help as well.

Remember, antibiotics are only effective for bacterial tonsillitis confirmed by a healthcare provider. Taking antibiotics unnecessarily can lead to antibiotic resistance and unwanted side effects. Never use them without medical advice.

How Is Tonsillitis Treated?

Viral tonsillitis typically does not require antibiotics and usually resolves on its own within a few days. On the other hand, if the tonsillitis is bacterial in origin, an antibiotic course is necessary to help shorten the duration of symptoms and prevent potential complications.

It's also important to note that tonsillitis, especially the bacterial kind is contagious. Practicing good hygiene can help prevent spreading it to others. This includes frequent hand washing and wearing a mask when you're around others, particularly those who are more vulnerable.

In Summary: What Should You Do If You Have a Sore Throat?

Keep an eye on how your symptoms evolve. If you develop a high fever, intense throat pain, difficulty swallowing, or swollen lymph nodes, it's best to see a healthcare professional. Avoid using antibiotics unless they've been specifically prescribed, as they only work against bacterial infections.

Take steps to soothe your throat and limit the risk of spreading illness to those around you. While a sore throat is usually a minor issue, it can sometimes be a sign of something more serious (ie: bacterial tonsillitis that requires proper treatment).

When in doubt, don’t hesitate to consult your doctor or pharmacist. Staying aware of changes in your symptoms and seeking timely medical advice is the best way to safeguard your health.

For more information visit: https://www.healthdirect.gov.au/tonsillitis

Back to blog